Unconsummated Marriage: A New Focus on Psychological Distress Faced by Indian Women and Possible Psychological Counselling Interventions
Sherin Lee Thomas* and S. Thenmozhi
Department of Counselling Psychology, University of Madras, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
*Address for Correspondence: Sherin Lee Thomas, Teaching Research Fellow, Department of Counselling Psychology, University of Madras, Chepauk, Chennai - 600 005, Tamil Nadu, India, Tel: +91-998-665-0012; E-mail: [email protected]
Submitted: 02 February 2018; Approved: 20 April 2019; Published: 23 April 2019
Citation this article: Thomas SL, Thenmozhi S. Unconsummated Marriage: A New Focus on Psychological Distress Faced by Indian Women and Possible Psychological Counselling Interventions. Int J Reprod Med Gynecol. 2019;5(1): 004-009.
Copyright: © 2019 Thomas SL, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited
Download Fulltext PDF
Introduction
In most societies, the wedding ceremony functions as symbolic consent between two adults - man and woman, to live together as husband and wife and for physical intimacy. One of the key components and perhaps determinants of a successful marriage is satisfactory sexual relations - penile-vaginal intercourse. Normal sexual function is a bio-psychosocial process which relies on a coordination of psychological, endocrine, vascular and neurological factors. It incorporates family, societal and religious beliefs and may be influenced by one’s health status, sexual knowledge, experience, attitude and interpersonal relationships. It is often assumed that every person who consents to marriage is physically, emotionally, psycho-logically as well as socially ready and able to have normal sexual intercourse [1].
Unconsummated marriage is a formal marital relationship in which penile penetration of the vagina did not take place, and the situation is a source of stress for either or both spouses [2]. Unconsummated Marriage (UM) is considered to be one of the complicated sexual issues that lead to multiple complications and problems for couples as well as the society [3]. UM (honeymoon or wedding night impotence, first-night erectile dysfunction and failure of defloration) is a common medical and social problem facing medical practitioners in conservative communities [4]. UM refers to marriage that wife and husband never have sexual relationship [5]. The exact prevalence of UM is unknown but it is thought to be more prevalent in traditional and conservative religious communities where premarital sexual exposure is strictly prohibited [3]. One of the earliest published accounts on unconsummated marriage was from the US by Malleson (1954). While the initial reports were from the West, mainly the USA most, if not all of the more recent publications have been from the Middle East and Mediterranean Countries such as Egypt, Iran, Israel, Saudi Arabia and Turkey [1].
In India’s male-dominated society, women are reluctant to discuss, or even reveal, these issues. But a study conducted by a Kerala-based institute on unconsummated relationships from 2006 to 2013 involving 12,718 people facing sexual problems reveals that the incidence of sexual dysfunction among women is not far behind as that in men. According to the data, 42 per cent of the relationships are not consummated due to problems in men and in 34 per cent of cases, the problem lies in the women. This study was perhaps the largest and first of this kind in India conducted by Promodu (2015) in his Institute of Sexual and Marital Health, Kerala, among a total of 12,718 sexual problem cases, 10977 patients comprising of 9605 (87.5%) men and 1372 (12.5%) women, 1926 (17.54%) were suffering from UM. Patients belonged to various diagnostic categories comprising of different age groups, genders, marital status, socio-economic background, languages, cultures, hailing from different parts of the country. Evaluation was done based on case history, clinical interview, physical examination, laboratory investigations and imaging procedures. Male, female and combined factors were found to be responsible for non- consummation of marriage [6].
A 2‐year study conducted in Hyderabad, India analysed 232 cases of UM from 2014 to 2015. The duration of UM ranged from 2 days to 15 years. 11 men came after divorce because of sex problem for an assurance of sexual fitness for another marriage. 3 men came for UM in second marriage also, two men with earlier success and failure now. 10 men were brought by families for certification of potency before a divorce. 37 couples came for having children as the sole or main cause, 31% came and discussed, 29% came discussed and investigated, but didn’t complete the course or didn’t come for follow up. 40% completed the treatment [7].
Little research has been conducted about unconsummated marriage in India, which is home to diverse cultures and traditions and most publications have originated from Middle Eastern countries and the available studies were case-reports in nature with emphasis on evaluation and treatment [1,10,19,22]. There is a lack of understanding among mental health and other multidisciplinary professionals about the psychological distress of women in an Unconsummated Marriage. Such knowledge is crucial to the development of possible effective psychological counselling interventions for the population. This paper attempts to fill gaps of knowledge about Unconsummated Marriage and expand the current understanding of its casual factors, its effect on psychological well-being of women and possible psychological counselling interventions. Because little research has been conducted on Unconsummated Marriage, the discussion will be based on literature gathered from theory and empirical findings of previous researches.
Aim
The purpose of this paper was to help close the existing knowledge gap concerning unconsummated marriage in India. This paper has gathered relevant literature with regard to UM to understand its etiological factors, psychological distress faced by Indian women and the scope for possible psychological counselling interventions.
Methods
A review of relevant published literature on UM from 1956 to 2018, was conducted using Pubmed psychinfo; psycharticles and journals from Google Scholar.
Causal Factors
As with any sexual dysfunction, the causes of an UM can be varied, complex, and interactive. The causal factors can be organic, sociological and psychological in nature. The other pertaining factors can be gender specific and also connected primarily to the marital relationship.
Organic Causes
Many a time, couples with sexual dysfunctions ended in being in a non-consummated marriage [8]. Women with unsatisfactory sexual functioning may complain of nonconsummation, severe vaginismus, orgasmic inadequacy, or other disturbances of sexual experience. Frigidity has been applied as a blanket term to cover all these situations [9]. Vaginismus has been reported as a leading cause for UM. In vaginismus, there is spasm of the perivaginal muscles sufficient to prevent penile entry or to make it uncomfortable [4]. Vaginismus is believed to be a psycho-physiologic disorder due to fear from actual or imagined negative experiences with penetration and/or organic pathology. Women with vaginismus have also been noted to have a lack of sex education [10]. 449 UM cases were evaluated in Turkey in between 2000 and 2004 and it was found that vaginismus was the most prominent cause in 81% of the cases, erectile dysfunction in 10.5%, premature ejaculation in 5% [11].
Sociological Causes
Instead of UM, the term “Unconsummated Relationship” could be useful to describe all over the world a relation were sexual intercourse never succeeded after a 6 months period of attempts and where a social pressure is not relevant and privacy is guaranteed. In cultural systems where marriage is mandatory to have sex, it is obvious that “relationship” means “marriage”. “First attempts dysfunction” could be a useful term to describe the impossibility to perform an intercourse because of social-cultural pressure to have an erection and then an intercourse as soon as possible, with the aim to be “integrated” in the society [2].
It is contended that in societies in which there is ample opportunity for premarital coitus and where it is not culturally or socially prohibited, UM is extremely rare as most individuals would have had premarital sexual experience either with the same partners or others [1]. Social and cultural constraints exert extra pressure on the couple. This is particularly evident in conservative societies where there is lack of sex education, sexual prohibition and misconception about genitalia along with unrealistic expectations [4]. There was a reported Indian case of marriage consummated after 22 years [12].
Female partners in the UM usually resist being involved in the therapy or attending the clinic for assessment. This negative attitude might be attributed to several cultural factors. Lack of sexual experience and absence of proper sexual education is associated with wrong stereotype about the role of male in the sexual relationship and a false believe that a normal male should be able to enforce his penis inside the vagina. Female partners will stop short of admitting having any problem fearing of social sequels including possible divorce, social humiliation and decrease chance to remarry. Even if they have the feeling or knowledge that they have a problem still the male partner and the close family would not consider this possible due to lack of knowledge and cultural heritage [13].
A 2‐year study conducted in Iran on 200 cases of UM reported that the main factor associated with an UM was the intense social pressure to accomplish hasty coitus with an unfamiliar woman (some men having had no social contact with their new bride) and in the presence of relatives waiting nearby for evidence of the bride’s virginity and confirmation of coitus The usual proof (the blood‐stained handkerchief) is so vital that in many unconsummated cases the groom cuts himself to provide the necessary blood; 27% of the present patients admitted doing so. The bridegroom is under intense psychological stress to avoid bringing disgrace upon himself and his family by failing to consummate the marriage. The bride’s phobia and misinformation adds to these unfavourable circumstances. Among rural people, inability to consummate a marriage is perceived as an unforgivable scandal for all the family and the bridegroom is treated with irony, resentment, reproach and anger [14]. To avoid socio-cultural rebuke, non-consummation of marriage was usually kept as a secret by the couple [8].
A case was reported in a study of a young Indian couple aged 28 and 25, with a history of failure to conceive and married for five years. Both were virgins at the time of marriage, which had been arranged by the two families. They were first cousins - their mothers being sisters and had therefore known each other since their childhood. They had not sought medical help till then. There was no relevant medical history. On sexual history inquiry both indicated they had regular satisfying sexual intercourse. There was no history of dyspareunia. The woman had regular menstrual cycles, bleeding for 4 to 6 days every 28 - 30 days, with no dysmenorrhoea or menorrhagia. On physical examination both were in good general health. The external genitalia were normal but the hymen was still intact with no evidence of defloration. Upon further inquiry on the nature of the “normal sexual intercourse”, the man indicated he had been having coitus inter-femora. The couple was counselled and given an explanation on the most likely cause of their infertility. They then received education on female sexual anatomy as well as normal sexual intercourse, i.e. penile-vaginal intercourse. The man was shown the vaginal introitus where he ought to penetrate. They were greatly relieved at the same time surprised. They confessed that no one had given them any sex education. They were encouraged to go home and try penile-vaginal intercourse. When they were seen two weeks later the couple was very happy they had been able to finally consummate their marriage and a year later they had a baby [1].
Psychogenic Causes
Psychogenic factors were the cause for UM in 74.4% of the 191 investigated patients in a study conducted in Egypt [4].
Performance anxiety
Performance anxiety is considered the major etiological factor for UM. This may contribute to or manifest as Premature Ejaculation (PE) of such severe degree as to make penile-vaginal penetration impossible, Erectile Dysfunction (ED) or vaginismus. Studies have reported (n = 191) that out of the 74.4% of psychological factors, performance anxiety contributed to 52.9% and in 21.5% other psychological distresses were responsible [1,4].
Some of the factors contributing to performance anxiety are lack of appropriate or poor knowledge and misconception about genital anatomy and sexual physiology (Sources of performance anxiety included fear of sexual failure, demand for sexual performance, fear of being rejected by the partner, the couple’s urge to consummate marriage in the wedding night, living in the same house with the family and a lengthy, noisy wedding ceremony Unreasonable expectations, traumatic early sexual experiences, restricted foreplay, impaired self-image and poor communication, all contributed to performance anxiety [4].
Fear of pain
In one of the largest and revealing studies on UM, Blazer (1964) (n = 1000), found that the main problem was fear of pain on the part of the woman [1].
Fear and fantasies
The fears and fantasies of women with UMs have been widely reported. Images of the vagina being too small, of its rupture, childbirth, rape, suffocation, degradation or of disgust for the male organs and semen are among the commonest. The earlier accounts found a link with childhood trauma from penetration in medical or surgical procedures or from sexual exposure, but such events are probably not unduly frequent in the lives of patients [15].
Anxiety and depression
Anxiety, schizophrenia and depression are the most common neuropsychiatric disorders in patients with sexual dysfunction [16]. A study [17] points out that six women in whom low sexual desire did not improve after treating the vaginismus, an underlying depression was thought to be responsible. Anti-depressant treatment produced heightened sexual desire in all six.
Negative body image
Findings of a study [3], evidenced that problems related to body image may interfere with sexual function and cause painful experiences. Body image is a complex set of conscious and unconscious emotions, attitudes, and perceptions, which a person has about his or her value, role and physical postures. Those who have negative body image are more likely to show avoidance behavior in sexual activity. In a number of studies conducted on UM, female body image problems such as negative attitudes toward their sexual organs, illusions about abnormal genitalia, thoughts about little vagina, and believing in having ugly bodies have been pointed out as related factors.
Parent fixation
A study [18] in 1956 reported that out of 50 cases of UM, larger group of those cases consisted of women who have reached genital maturity but have remained fixated to their father, and those are the cases which could be tackled quickly and easily. The smaller and more difficult group consisted of women who had either remained fixated to their mothers or who had regressed to such fixation because of their disposition or because of external circumstances. Those subjects needed more time and more expert handling.
Other psychogenic causes: include traumatic sexual experience, uncooperative female, interpersonal conflict and/or lack of sexual knowledge [4].
Gender Specific Causes by Women
Inability by the female partner to allow penile penetration may occur as a result of mechanical, physiological, emotional factors, or a combination thereof. In many cases, simple ignorance regarding female anatomy and a lack of sexual experience coupled with a history that did not include tampon use, self-exploration, or penetrative masturbation may be causal factors in preventing intercourse from occurring.
Mechanical factors may also include anatomical anomalies such as a rigid or septate hymen. Insufficient lubrication, the presence of pain with attempted intercourse, fear, and anxiety are all potential factors contributing to penetration failure. As in any case of UM, a thorough history and physical examination is critical in ruling out painful conditions, such as vulvar vestibulitis syndrome [19]. UM may also arise due to a role of the bride to delay coitus [13].
A recent Indian study [6] on UM revealed that 1955 females out of the total of 15,357 patients sought treatment for sexual problems and it was found that among the females, vaginismus was the commonest cause for UM accounting for 95.23% followed by sexual aversion disorder 2.46%, sexual desire disorder 1.85% and 0.46% lesbian orientation.
Gender Specific Causes by Men
Two primary factors contribute to the male spouse’s inability to achieve vaginally contained penetration: Erectile Dysfunction (ED) and Premature Ejaculation (PE) [19]. UM can also be due to the role of male partner who have sex with men (MSM) and hypogonadism [13]. UM can also arise due to abuse of alcohol and drugs apart from other physical illness.
A study [6] in Kerala, India among a total of 15,357 patients who sought treatment for sexual problems, 13402 males reported that among male factors for UM, erectile dysfunction was found to be the top ranking cause accounting for 79.37% followed by premature ejaculation 12.01%, lack of sexual desire 3.92%, homosexual orientation 2.79%, sexual aversion disorder 1.31% and disorders of sexual preference 0.61%.
Effect of Unconsummated Marriage on the Psychological Well-Being of Women
Satisfying sexual relation is critical for well-being of individuals and survival of their marriages [1]. UM has several unpleasant consequences. The most natural consequence of UM is infertility that imposes a heavy emotional burden on the couple [3]. In a collectivistic society, it can be stressful to manage the inquisitive queries by extended family and community about the delay in parenthood. Women experience considerable distress because of their “barrenness”. A recent Indian study [20] on infertility in Chennai, confirms that one of the partners stress and depression is strongly correlated to the level of stress and depression of their spouses. Many couples avoid consultation and one of the reasons is the reluctance of the couples to admit the problem due to their feelings of guilt, shame, or inadequacy, which causes a conflict between their needs to seek help and to conceal their difficulty [2].
Women with vaginismus generally experience shame, disgust and dislike toward their genitals and they frequently have or have had other phobias. It is troublesome not only because the women and their partners are unable to enjoy intercourse, but also because their self-esteem is affected by the repeated failures or by avoidance of intimate relations entirely [21]. A study [10] reported of a case of vaginismus from Mumbai, India in which the wife would push her husband away and they would both end up feeling hurt and angry.
Vaginismus interferes with coitus and causes distress and interpersonal difficulty. Sexual dysfunction is a common problem which leads to inter-personal problems and marital discord. The transition between a relationship issue and a sexual problem may not be apparent. The couple may deny the primary issue and force the secondary problem in excess for a solution. The determination of the primary cause and the couple’s approach to treatment are essential for the prognosis [22].
Possible Psychological Counselling Interventions
Dysfunction underlying non consummation of marriage is largely treatable [23]. Findings of a retrospective study [16] on Indian patients with sexual dysfunction pointed that UM was observed in about 30% patients and this finding is particularly important in a country like India because, generally most patients do not talk about sexual matters. In the Indian scenario where the talk about sex is taboo and limited among partners, it becomes very essential to first improve their communication so as to improve the sex related issues [10]. Clearly, earlier recognition of a couple’s inability to experience intercourse is needed. Identification of the etiological factors of UM may be essential for the proper management to achieve a successful outcome [4,17].
As in most therapeutic relationships, the initial education will come from the clients themselves [19]. Sex education and public awareness is important to help young couple to enjoy healthy sexual life. Sex hygiene is an essential part of sex education as many couples do not communicate to their partners about body odour or bad breath [10,13]. For the couples in whom poor knowledge of sexual matters was thought to be the major cause, the history at first sounded like vaginismus. Once information was given with the aid of diagrams, models and physical examination, progress was rapid [17]. UM is quite frequent in the Arab Islamic world and the best treatment is prevention based on sexual education of youngsters and treatment of sexual dysfunctions for people who consult before marriage [24].
One of the earliest reported studies [18] on therapeutic and psychological approach to UM derived from results of treating 50 such cases stressed that where no anatomical abnormality exists, the approach should be from the psychological side and that gynaecologist or general practitioner should co-operate with psychotherapist. In a typical review study [14] of 159 cases of UM treated by psychotherapy, 60% were consummated by 6 months and 72% by 2 years.
Successful treatment of “frigidity” has been accomplished by many forms of psychotherapy, including behavior therapy and non-consummation has been very successfully treated [9]. Some behaviour therapists have claimed important advantages from involving husbands in their wives’ treatment; it was considered that this participation educated him to understand his wife’s difficulties better and increased his motivation to help her, improved communication between the couple, and assisted generalization of the wife’s relaxation in the treatment setting to daily life situations [15].
Findings of a study [25] reported on 10 Israeli women and their husbands who were referred to the clinic because of UM due to fear of vaginal penetration and the treatment technique consisted of a combination of individual psychotherapy for the wife, direct mechanical therapy, and joint marital therapy. With treatment extending over a period of about 6 months, 7 of the couples were successfully treated and 4 of the wives became pregnant.
A recent Iranian study [26] points out that treatment with multi-dimensional approach for an Iranian couple (vaginismus and PTSD) with UM after 6 years included methods like narrative exposure therapy, educating the anatomy of female and male reproductive system, correcting misconceptions, educating foreplay, educating body exploring and non-sexual and sexual massage and penetrating the vagina first by women finger and then men’s after relaxation. The entire stages of the treatment lasted for four sessions and at the one-month follow-up couple’s satisfaction was desirable.
Findings of a study [10] conducted in Mumbai, India reported of a couple who had an UM of 5 years due to vaginismus in the wife and ED in the husband. It took 8 sessions of sex therapy with the couple without the use of medication. The sessions included sexual education, behavioural techniques like graded insertion of fingers, homework assignments and cognitive behaviour therapy which resulted in the couple consummating their marriage.
Another Indian study [27] pointed that counselling intervention can be given to couples or individual partners seeking help to resolve marital discord or to improve well-being of the marriage through couple therapy, marital therapy, family therapy or individual psychotherapy. Counselling to overcome stigma and enhance awareness on sexuality is an essential step in management.
All cases of UM treated continued to be seen not only until consummation had been achieved, but until some degree of orgastic pleasure had been attained [18].
Multidisciplinary approach: An Indian study [22] was conducted in Manipal to understand the causes of UM and the history taking included detailed medical examinations (drugs, drug abuse, surgical history, progression through puberty and developmental milestones). The sexual history included a review of the person’s educational, familial and religious background. Moreover, gender identity, sexual orientation and sexual behaviour (e.g. desires, fantasies, current and previous interpersonal sexual activity, same sex relations, rejection experience, sexual abuse and body image) were carefully explored. The findings of the study stressed that whatever the treatment method, history must be taken from both the sexual partners, a distinctive diagnosis of the sexual problem must be made by the multidisciplinary team, and the primary sexual issue must be correctly identified.
Successful treatment of a case of UM involved the expertise of an urologist, gynecologist, and psychologist working together in an interdisciplinary clinic to treat sexual dysfunction. There are several effective psychological and pharmacological therapeutic approaches to treat female sexual disorders [27,28]. An Indian study [22] pointed that in addition to providing explicit sex education and behavioral counselling, physicians often find prescription medications useful. An inadequate knowledge about sexual relationship and dependency to paternal family are of the most important and frequent reasons of this disorder, it seems sexual relation education in educational and health centers in India is necessary.
Primary care physicians, gynecologists and urologists should be more aware about vaginismus as a possible cause of UM [13]. A case study [29] of an Iranian couple who had under gone treatment due to 14 years history of UM and wanting a child which comprised of psychiatric assessment, sex therapy methods for the couple and then individual psychotherapy was performed for wife to reduce anxiety.
Findings of an Indian clinical study [7] reported that, 93 men out of 232 clients who completed treatment for UM in an exclusive sexual medicine clinic in Hyderabad, 4 failed to consummate, 3 men consummated the marriage on the same day without treatment. Simple method of sildenafil, anxiolytic, lubricant and teaching the position of sex made 62 men to consummate. Others were given specific treatments for the cause, 28 were advised sex therapy, 17 underwent, two dropped, one partial success and others were successful.
Discussion
The findings of this study highlighted the casual factors of UM contributed by either partner in the marriage. This study lends support to create awareness among individuals both in premarital and post-marital context due to the strong pressure and cultural systems surrounding consummation of marriage in India and also because sex related topics are considered taboo. This study revealed the possibility of treatment for UM available even from a psychologist rather than waiting to consult a gynaecologist and that married couples should be engaged in frank conversation about difficulties arising due to various casual factors of UM as highlighted in this study. The possible psychological interventions suggest that consulting a psychologist may sometimes involve multidisciplinary approach too to rule out whether it is a female or both shared organic etiology.
It is observed that when one or both of the partner(s) suffers in UM, it produces psychological distress. The further involvement of people outside the marriage such as parents and community may explain how it aggravates the psychological health of the women negatively. Indian women usually shy away from expressing the real problem or due to poor knowledge covertly suffer within UM.
Findings of this study revealed that intervention begins with education of breaking free from taboo to talk or seek help with regard to UM and developing better communication among married couples by seeking help from a professional counsellor or psychologist which paves way for improving marital relationship and thus promotes a psychologically healthier family instead of being psychologically distressed within an UM. Based on the previous researches, the findings of this study shows the importance of mental health care professionals such as psychologists and psychiatrists to have enough information regarding UM to facilitate in reducing psychological distress of women suffering in UM.
Conclusion
It is concluded from this study that early identification and management of the causal factors, whether organic, psychogenic or sociological in nature can help an Indian women suffering in an UM. Detailed history of patients might reveal a cause of sexual dysfunction which only needs effective counselling and not psychotropic medicines, potentially avoiding the misuse of these medicines.
Psychological support along with multidisciplinary approach in the treatment of etiology of UM is essential for the overall well-being of the Indian women in an UM, especially because of the immense pressure faced in Indian cultural and societal context.
The possibilities of using this study to aid those who suffer in Unconsummated Marriage are extremely promising. This will benefit counsellors to help women deal with their psychological distress. This new perspective could also benefit society, as it would encourage a more psychologically healthy populace.
- Lema V M. Unconsummated marriage in Sub-Saharan Africa: Case Reports. Afr J Reprod Health. 2014; 18: 159-165. https://goo.gl/9HVHTf
- Silvaggi M, Michetti P M, Rossi R, Fabrizi A, Tripodi F, Simonelli C. Is “Unconsummated Marriage” still an appropriate term? A snapshot of reality. Perceptions Reprod Med. 2017; 1: 506. https://goo.gl/vLq3VC
- Hosseini S, Noroozi M, Montazery G. Investigating the relation between women’s body image and unconsummated marriage. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res. 2017; 22: 363-366. https://goo.gl/Npxbkq
- Badran W, Moamen N, Fahmy I, El Karaksy A, Abdel Nasser TM, Ghanem H. Etiological factors of unconsummated marriage. Int J Impot Res. 2006; 18: 458-463.
- Naseri A, Malekirad A.A, Gorjinia A, Ashayeri H, Fathi A. Unconsummated Marriage. Health. 2015; 7: 207-210. https://goo.gl/fc4RjQ
- Promodu K. Unconsummated marriages hindering conception and pregnancy, 2015. https://goo.gl/6nD293
- Alla S R. Clinical profile of unconsummated marriages. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2017; 14: 103.
- Patel A, Sharma P S V N, Narayan P, Nair B V S, Narayanakurup D, Pai P J. Distress in infertile males in manipal-india: a clinic based study. Journal of Reproduction & Infertility, 2016; 17: 213–220.
- Faulk M. “Frigidity”: A critical review. Arch Sex Behav. 1973; 2: 257-66. https://goo.gl/twVc7g
- Sawant N, Kumar A, Dhuri C. Sex therapy in a case of unconsummated marriage. Clinical Medicine Journal. 2015: 1: 98-100.
- Ozdemir O, Simsek F, Ozkardes S, Incesu C, Karakoc B. The unconsummated marriage: its frequency and clinical characteristics in a sexual dysfunction clinic. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 2008; 34: 268-279. https://goo.gl/ik9B1i
- Chakrabarti N, Sinha V. Marriage consummated after 22 years: a case report. J Sex Marital Ther. 2002; 28: 301-304. https://goo.gl/YrXJ9N
- Ghazi S, Shaltout A. Unconsummated marriage: relationship between honeymoon impotence and vaginismus. Medical Journal of Cairo University. 2009; 77: 103-107. https://goo.gl/X4U3iy
- Zargooshi J. Unconsummated marriage: clarification of aetiology; treatment with intracorporeal injection. BJU Int. 2000; 86: 75-79. https://goo.gl/bz3MCc
- Chisholm I D. Sexual problems in marriage: non-consummation. Postgraduate Medical Journal. 1972; 48: 544-547. https://goo.gl/3ispNn
- Mutha A S, Kulkarni V R, Beldar A S, Patel S B. Use of neuro-psychiatry medicines in patients with sexual dysfunction: a retrospective study. International Journal of Basic & Clinical Pharmacology. 2017; 6: 563-567. https://goo.gl/DHXSSW
- Basson R. Assessment and management of the couple with an unconsummated marriage. Journal of Society of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada. 1998; 20: 33-42. https://goo.gl/eKjGth
- Abraham H C. Therapeutic and psychological approach to cases of unconsummated marriage. Br Med J. 1956; 1: 837-839. https://goo.gl/1LZy6p
- Ribner D S, Rosenbaum T Y. Evaluation and Treatment of Unconsummated Marriages among Orthodox Jewish Couples. J Sex Marital Ther. 2005; 31: 341–353. https://goo.gl/T5mq5i
- Thenmozhi S, Bhaskar S, Kavitha Gautham K S. Stress and depression during assisted reproductive technology treatment - need for infertility counselling. International Journal of Reproductive Medicine and Gynecology. 2018; 4: 028-033. https://goo.gl/TGA4A6
- Jeng C J. The pathophysiology and etiology of vaginismus. Taiwanese Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology. 2004; 43: 10-15. https://goo.gl/Eod4XA
- Latha K S, Sahana M, Bhat S M, Haridas K. Unconsummated marriage and its etiological factors: A Case series. Middle East Journal of Psychiatry and Alzheimers. 2014; 4: 18-22.
- Addar M H. The unconsummated marriage: causes and management. Clin Exp Obstet Gynecol. 2004; 31: 279-81. https://goo.gl/VbBs6u
- Nabil M, Mhiri Smaoui W, Bouassida M, Chabchoub K, Masmoudi J, Hadjslimen M, et al. Unconsummated marriage in the Arab Islamic world: Tunisian experience. Sexologies, 2013; 22: 71-76. https://goo.gl/HJurQy
- Davidson S, Yftach R. The therapy of the unconsummated marriage. Psychotherapy: Theory, research & practice. 1976; 13: 418-419. https://goo.gl/rhmAKH
- Bokaie M, Khalesi Z, Yasini Ardekani S M. Diagnosis and treatment of unconsummated marriage in an Iranian couple. Afr Health Sci. 2017; 17: 632-636. https://goo.gl/Fh45ay
- Sathyanarana Rao T S, Nagaraj A M. Female sexuality. Indian J Psychiatry. 2015; 57: 296-302. https://goo.gl/HPCZUu
- Schover LR, Montague DK, Youngs DD. Multidisciplinary treatment of an unconsummated marriage with organic factors in both spouses. Cleve Clin J Med. 1993; 60: 72-74. https://goo.gl/6H2TRwMirzaie N. A fourteen year unconsummated marriage and its successful treatment (a case report). Journal of reproduction and Fertility. 2002; 3: 59-63. https://goo.gl/SqURSX
Sign up for Article Alerts